Sudoku Desk

Empty Rectangle

A box whose candidates form a cross, combined with a strong link.

Very HardAlso known as: ER

An Empty Rectangle looks at one digit inside one box. If all its candidates in the box lie on a single row and a single column (forming an L or a cross), the box’s copy of the digit must be on that row or that column.

Combined with a strong link elsewhere — a line where the digit has only two spots — this produces an elimination.

The rule

If a box’s candidates for a digit fit on one row plus one column, and a strong link lines up with one arm, remove the digit where the strong link’s other end meets the other arm.

How to spot it

  1. Find a box where a digit’s candidates can be covered by one row and one column. The rest of the box is “empty” of the digit.
  2. Look for a strong link (a column or row with two candidates) whose one end lines up with one arm of the box.
  3. Follow the link to its other end. Where that end’s line crosses the box’s other arm, the digit can be removed.

Why it works

If the strong link’s near end isn’t the digit, the far end is. If the near end is the digit, it blocks that arm of the box, so the box’s digit must be on the other arm. Either way, the target cell sees the digit.

Example from a real puzzle

This position comes from one of Sudoku Desk’s Expert daily puzzles, at the moment the Empty Rectangle is the next logical step. Small grey digits are the remaining candidates.

Empty Rectangle example 1C1R1C2R2C3R3C4R4C5R5C6R6C7R7C8R8C9R9596437182473261894545787125936761779345821925398147614984972651313917657893214515191857261349134325916475984444444
  • Pattern
  • Chain
  • Key candidates
  • Removed / concluded
  • 5Given
  • 5Solved so far
  1. In box 7, every candidate 4 sits on one row and one column that cross at R7C2 — an “empty rectangle”. So box 7’s 4 lies somewhere on that row or that column.
  2. R3C2 and R3C9 are the only two 4’s in their line (a strong link): one of them is 4. R3C2 lines up with the empty rectangle.
  3. Trace it through: if box 7’s 4 isn’t on the arm pointing at R3C2, then R3C9 is 4. Either way, a 4 ends up seeing R7C9.
  4. So R7C9 can’t be 4.

Open this position in Sudoku DeskCandidates are filled in. Find the Empty Rectangle yourself, or press 💡 for a step-by-step hint.

Practise it

Your turn. Each puzzle below has a Empty Rectangle waiting to be found. Tap the cell, pick the candidate it removes, and you’ll see straight away if you’re right. Stuck? Take a hint.

Tips

  • Box candidates in a single row or column also count: that is just a pointing pair.
Practise it. Empty Rectangle shows up in Very Hard puzzles and harder. Every day there are five new puzzles — the same for everyone.
Play today’s Very Hard puzzle

Related techniques

Two-String KiteSkyscraperPointing Pairs & Box/Line Reduction