Sudoku Desk

Finned X-Wing

An X-Wing with one extra candidate — the fin.

ExpertAlso known as: Finned Fish, Sashimi X-Wing (variant)

A Finned X-Wing is an X-Wing that is spoiled by one or two extra candidates in one of its rows. Those extra cells are called the fin, and they must sit in the same box as one corner of the X-Wing.

You can’t make the normal X-Wing eliminations, but you can make the ones that are true whether or not the fin is the digit.

The rule

Remove the digit from cells that are in a cover column of the X-Wing and in the same box as the fin.

How to spot it

  1. Find a near-X-Wing: one row is perfect, the other has one or two extra candidates for the digit.
  2. Check that the extra candidates (the fin) are in the same box as one of that row’s X-Wing cells.
  3. Look for cells in that box which are also in one of the X-Wing’s columns. Those cells can’t be the digit.

Why it works

Either the fin holds the digit, or it doesn’t. If it doesn’t, the pattern is a real X-Wing and the digit is removed from the cover columns. If it does, every cell in the fin’s box loses the digit. The target cells are in both groups, so they lose the digit in both cases.

When to look for it

Check for a Finned X-Wing whenever an X-Wing search almost works: one base row is perfect and the other has one or two extra candidates for the digit. If the extras sit together in the box of one X-Wing corner, you have a fin.

Example from a real puzzle

This position comes from one of Sudoku Desk’s Expert daily puzzles, at the moment the Finned X-Wing is the next logical step. Small grey digits are the remaining candidates.

Finned X-Wing example 1C1R1C2R2C3R3C4R4C5R5C6R6C7R7C8R8C9R9334862341755261497498373415349864921573434286923378651468495132734639214975849128754936875346349249199999
  • Pattern
  • Key candidates
  • Removed / concluded
  • 5Given
  • 5Solved so far
  1. This is almost an X-Wing on digit 9 in rows 1, 5, but one row has an extra cell or two — the fin (R1C1).
  2. If the fish part holds, 9 is removed from the cover columns as usual. If instead the fin is the 9, it sits in the same box as R3C2.
  3. Either way, R3C2 — which sees both the fin’s box and a cover column — can’t be 9.

Open this position in Sudoku DeskCandidates are filled in. Find the Finned X-Wing yourself, or press 💡 for a step-by-step hint.

Another example

The same pattern in a different Expert puzzle, this time with digit 4. Try to spot it before reading the steps.

Finned X-Wing example 2C1R1C2R2C3R3C4R4C5R5C6R6C7R7C8R8C9R91473472895617917617453288521736141479148365147926174792381455298714143637856291717476139825729541768344444
  • Pattern
  • Key candidates
  • Removed / concluded
  • 5Given
  • 5Solved so far
  1. This is almost an X-Wing on digit 4 in columns 2, 9, but one column has an extra cell or two — the fin (R8C9).
  2. If the fish part holds, 4 is removed from the cover rows as usual. If instead the fin is the 4, it sits in the same box as R7C8.
  3. Either way, R7C8 — which sees both the fin’s box and a cover row — can’t be 4.

Open this position in Sudoku DeskCandidates are filled in. Find the Finned X-Wing yourself, or press 💡 for a step-by-step hint.

One more example

The same pattern in a different Expert puzzle, this time with digit 3. Try to spot it before reading the steps.

Finned X-Wing example 3C1R1C2R2C3R3C4R4C5R5C6R6C7R7C8R8C9R95389474721671286534349946213185757895347347263471471358635922631457945847324571571796818962474545657349812433333
  • Pattern
  • Key candidates
  • Removed / concluded
  • 5Given
  • 5Solved so far
  1. This is almost an X-Wing on digit 3 in columns 6, 9, but one column has an extra cell or two — the fin (R9C9).
  2. If the fish part holds, 3 is removed from the cover rows as usual. If instead the fin is the 3, it sits in the same box as R8C8.
  3. Either way, R8C8 — which sees both the fin’s box and a cover row — can’t be 3.

Open this position in Sudoku DeskCandidates are filled in. Find the Finned X-Wing yourself, or press 💡 for a step-by-step hint.

Practise it

Your turn. Each puzzle below has a Finned X-Wing waiting to be found. Tap the cell, pick the candidate it removes, and you’ll see straight away if you’re right. Stuck? Take a hint.

Tips

  • The eliminations are few — usually one or two cells — but they often break a puzzle open.
  • If a corner of the X-Wing is missing entirely and only the fin makes it work, it is called a Sashimi X-Wing. The same rule applies.

Common mistakes

  • Eliminating from the whole cover column, as with a plain X-Wing. Only cells in the fin’s box are safe to clear.
  • Accepting fin cells spread over different boxes. All fin cells must share one box – the box of an X-Wing corner.
  • Forgetting that the target must also be in a cover column. A cell in the fin’s box outside the X-Wing’s columns is not affected.
  • Using it on a base line with too many extras. If the extra candidates can’t all be covered by one box, there is no fin.
Practise it. Finned X-Wing shows up in Expert puzzles and harder. Every day there are five new puzzles — the same for everyone.
Play today’s Expert puzzle

Frequently asked questions

What is the fin in a Finned X-Wing?

The fin is one or two extra candidates for the digit in one of the base rows (or columns) that stop the pattern from being a plain X-Wing. All fin cells must be in the same box as one corner of the X-Wing.

Why are there so few eliminations?

Only cells that would lose the digit in both cases — fin true or fin false — can be cleared. Those are the cells in a cover column of the X-Wing that are also in the fin’s box, usually one or two cells.

What is a Sashimi X-Wing?

A Finned X-Wing where one corner of the X-Wing is missing altogether, so the pattern only works thanks to the fin. The eliminations follow exactly the same rule.

Is there a Finned Swordfish too?

Yes. The same idea works on three rows and three columns: see Finned Swordfish.

Related techniques

X-WingFinned Swordfish